Michelangelo's

Brian Ralph 2 months ago

Wings were exceptional. Great sauce and cooked as requested (extra crispy). Pizza was good, but sausage was a little chewy/soft. Liked the sauce and crust. Staff were extremely friendly and courteous.

Red Rhapsody 5 months ago

Great food (except the veal parm I think) but they were so backed up with four tables they took almost an hour and a half to get our food out. Which was difficult for our hungry child but we managed for awhile. About a 20 minute wait before we were seated and an hour for food. They forgot our utensils and we had to get up to get our own because they didn't come back to the table for awhile. Even though there was someone standing there hosting. Usually we have a great experience but we probably aren't gonna visit on a weekend anymore.

Mac Calvasina Edited 7 months ago

The food at Michelangelo's is absolutely delicious. One of my favorite Italian restaurants (if not my favorite) in Binghamton. I'm actually disappointed in myself for not going here sooner. Huge portions of quality food for a very fair price. Eggplant parm & chicken parm specifically are phenomenal, as is their bruschetta and garlic knots. My only gripe is that they are greatly limited in regard to space; I wish they were twice the size & had more room as far as indoor dining and even parking. They also seem to quite frequently have a wait time for seating due to this fact (unless you arrive super early, and even then there may be a wait!). But I assure you, it is well worth the wait and you will be very impressed w/ the food and the service. Edit: Tried to order take-out tonight from them and they hung up on my 3 times. Can't get through. I'm aware that it's Valentine's Day, but please, PLEASE practice better service than this. Take the call and simply say, "sorry, we are not accepting take-out orders at this time." Had to readjust my rating due to this.

Scott Parks Edited 7 months ago

Great meal. Very reasonable prices. I will come again! 02/2026 - Still good!

Holly Mosher a year ago

This place was a recommendation & it was one of the best we ever received. This unassuming longterm restaurant was packed even between lunch & dinner times, slight wait for a table. The staff we encountered was very friendly & attentive. The food was absolutely delicious, fresh & plentiful. Salad was fresh fresh! Their red & alfredo sauces were some of the best we tasted, better than mine! Meatballs are excellent. Brought home leftovers for the following day. Listed as a pizza place but more like grandma's italian dishes place. This place is well worth the detour when traveling. We will be back.